Conversion Optimization

Conversion Optimization

Shipping Insurance: Do You Really Need It?

Shipping Insurance: Do You Really Need It?

Shipping Insurance: Do You Really Need It?

Oct 28, 2024

|

5

min read

Shipping insurance is a frequently overlooked aspect of eCommerce logistics—but it can play a critical role in protecting your bottom line. With customer expectations higher than ever, is it something your business should invest in?

What is shipping insurance?

Shipping insurance is a service that reimburses senders for packages that are lost, stolen, or damaged during transit. It is typically offered by carriers (like USPS, UPS, FedEx) or third-party insurers.

When is it worth it?

  • You ship high-value or fragile items.

  • Your business is international or deals with long shipping routes.

  • You’ve experienced frequent loss or damage in transit.

📦 Compare the benefits of shipping insurance via Easyship’s insurance breakdown.

Pros of shipping insurance

  • Financial protection in case of loss or damage

  • Enhances customer satisfaction with issue resolution

  • Provides peace of mind to both seller and buyer

🔗 See how Shippo outlines coverage limits and timelines.

Cons of shipping insurance

  • Added cost per package, especially for low-margin products

  • Claim process may be slow or require extensive documentation

  • Not all products or destinations may be eligible

📄 Review FedEx's terms and coverage.

Alternatives to paid insurance

  • Use carriers with default liability coverage (e.g., USPS includes up to $100).

  • Implement quality packaging and fulfillment procedures to minimize risk.

  • Clearly communicate shipping policies and offer fast replacements.

✅ Explore how Pirate Ship offers free insurance up to $100.

Should small businesses get shipping insurance?

If your average order value is high, or you’re scaling internationally, insurance may be a smart safeguard. For businesses with low-risk, low-cost products, it might be more cost-effective to absorb occasional losses instead.

📊 Use this Shipping Insurance ROI Calculator to help assess your situation.


How Does Shipping Insurance Protect Your Small Business?

Shipping insurance acts as a safety net against potential losses that can occur during transit. Whether an item is lost, damaged, or stolen, insurance coverage can reimburse businesses, helping to maintain customer satisfaction and preserve revenue. Without this safeguard in place, small businesses may have to bear the cost of replacing goods, which can eat into their profit margins.

Benefits of Shipping Insurance

The advantages of having shipping insurance extend beyond monetary reimbursement. Below are some of the key benefits:

  • Enhanced customer trust

Customers are more likely to purchase from businesses that have a clear policy for handling unfortunate shipping issues. Knowing that items are insured builds confidence in your brand.

  • Financial protection

Shipping insurance ensures businesses are not left covering the total cost for high-value or bulk orders lost in transit.

  • Reduced risk for international shipping

With global shipping involving more touchpoints, the probability of delays or losses increases. Insurance helps mitigate those risks.

  • Competitive advantage

Offering insured shipments can set your business apart from competitors, creating a stronger selling point for hesitant buyers.

Scenarios Where Shipping Insurance Makes Sense

Small businesses should assess specific instances to determine whether to insure shipments:

  1. High-value items

Products like jewelry, electronics, or collectibles benefit from the protection insurance offers due to their significant replacement cost.

  1. Fragile goods

Glassware, ceramics, or other delicate items can easily sustain damage in transport, making insurance a practical choice.

  1. Unpredictable shipping routes

International or remote destinations often come with a higher risk of package mishandling. Insurance provides reassurance and compensation if issues arise.

  1. Seasonal spikes in orders

During busy shopping seasons like the holidays, shipping challenges tend to increase, making insurance an extra layer of preparedness.

When Is Shipping Insurance Not Necessary?

While shipping insurance provides peace of mind, it might not always be required. The following cases may not justify the cost:

Cases Where You Can Skip Insurance:

  • Low-cost items

If your products are inexpensive, the cost of replacing them may be lower than the insurance premiums.

  • Reliable carriers with coverage

Some carriers, such as Pirate Ship with free coverage up to $100, already include insurance as part of their service.

  • Consistently safe shipping routes

If you've established a history of safe deliveries to certain regions, additional insurance could be unnecessary.

How to Choose the Right Shipping Insurance?

To pick the most suitable shipping insurance for your business, consider the following steps:

  1. Analyze Order Value

For small businesses, keeping track of average order value can help guide insurance decisions.

  1. Evaluate Your Shipping History

Review past data for losses or damage. Identify whether these incidents were frequent enough to justify insurance.

  1. Compare Providers

There are many options for shipping insurance, ranging from in-house solutions with your carrier to third-party providers offering more customizable plans.

  1. Read the Fine Print

Policies vary in terms of coverage limitations and claim submission periods, so ensure you fully understand the terms.

Tools to Help You Decide

Want more clarity on whether shipping insurance is right for you? Consider leveraging tools like these:

Key Questions to Ask Your Shipping Provider

Before committing to additional insurance, ask your shipping provider:

  • Are there any included coverage options, and what do they entail?

  • What documentation is required to submit a claim for lost or damaged goods?

  • How long does the claims process typically take?

Common Myths About Shipping Insurance

"Insurance Is Too Expensive for Small Businesses"

Truthfully, many shipping insurance options are highly affordable, especially for items with high-value margins. Comparing third-party options like Route or your carrier’s insurance can help you find cost-efficient coverage.

"Only Big Companies Need Insurance"

Even small losses can affect small businesses significantly. Insuring just a portion of your shipments can protect you from financial setbacks without breaking the bank.

"Claims Always Get Denied"

While denials happen in cases of incomplete documentation, submitting complete claims with proper proof is usually sufficient to ensure reimbursement.

Takeaways To Protect Your Small Business

By integrating shipping insurance wisely into your logistics strategy, you can reduce risk, enhance customer trust, and protect your bottom line. Implement the following key steps:

  • Clearly communicate your replacement and refund policies on insured items.

  • Use services with included insurance like Pirate Ship or consider third-party coverage.

  • Regularly review your shipping performance to decide which orders need insurance most.

With these measures, your small business can operate smoothly while staying prepared for potential hiccups!

Final thoughts

Shipping insurance isn’t a one-size-fits-all solution. Evaluate your business model, products, customer expectations, and loss history to determine if the investment makes sense. Protecting your reputation and profit margins should always be a top priority.

📬 Learn more from Shopify’s shipping protection guide.

Share It On: